News Flash Home
The original item was published from 9/21/2020 4:09:49 PM to 9/22/2021 12:00:05 AM.

News Flash

All News

Posted on: September 21, 2020

[ARCHIVED] Judge denies Robinsons’ $800,000 attorneys fees request

scales of justice

CLARKSVILLE, Tenn. –  Despite Jeff and Sherri Robinson’s request for more than $800,000 in attorneys fees in their ongoing lawsuit against the City, the trial court has ordered the City to pay only $30,000.

Additionally, the ruling says only two local attorneys out of five lawyers, including two Nashville attorneys, representing the Robinsons and their Franklin Street Corporation be compensated in connection with the one claim out of six on which they were successful.  

In November 2019, a Montgomery County Circuit Court jury returned a verdict in favor of the Robinsons’ Franklin Street Corporation on a claim of inverse condemnation, the last remaining count in the lawsuit, which argued that the City had “taken” a small part of land owned by the plaintiffs when it installed a sewer line near the Robinsons’ Blackhorse Pub & Brewery at 132 Franklin St.

The jury awarded the Robinsons damages of $8,335. They had sought more than $10 million dollars in alleged damages.

Last week, Davidson County Circuit Court Judge Joseph P. Binkley Jr., who was assigned the case after local judges recused themselves, issued his ruling on the plaintiff’s attorney fee request.

“The court concludes that a reasonable fee award for attorneys Mark R. Olson and Taylor R. Dahl, which includes the time expended by both attorneys and their paralegals, is $30,000,” the judge wrote.

Mayor Joe Pitts called the judge’s order “a major legal victory for the citizens of Clarksville.” 

“The City has successfully defended itself against a torrent of legal claims and maneuvers seeking millions of dollars in damages and more than $800,000 in attorneys fees,” Mayor Pitts said Monday. “To date, the city has prevailed on five of six claims brought by the Robinsons. On the single count they won, a jury awarded the plaintiffs $8,335 in damages and the judge awarded them $30,000 in lawyers fees. These results vindicate the City’s decisions to protect taxpayers’ interests in court and adhere to the principle that the City should not pay off meritless claims, and should not pay more than a reasonable amount for legally valid claims.” 

In awarding attorneys fees, Judge Binkley wrote that the Robinsons’ “attorneys’ explanations of their time entries do not provide the required sufficient detail ...  for the Court to determine that the stated hours were actually and reasonably spent in the prosecution of the inverse condemnation claim.”

Binkley wrote that the “most appropriate and fair method to assess the attorney fees is to determine the range that comparable attorneys would charge to try an inverse condemnation case in Clarksville.” In making this determination, the Court relied heavily on the affidavits of Clarksville attorneys Dan L. Nolan, Roger A: Maness, Mark A. Rassas and M. Joel Wallace, which the City presented in its response to the plaintiffs’ request for award of fees.

“The Court finds that a reasonable hourly rate for Mr. Olson’s attorney time is $350; a reasonable hourly rate for Ms. Dahl’s attorney time is $200, and a reasonable hourly rate for their paralegals’ time is $75. The Court also finds that a reasonable amount of time to prepare and to try this inverse condemnation case to a jury verdict is approximately 100 hours,” the order said.

The order on the attorneys’ fees represents the latest chapter in a long legal battle. In 2016, the Robinsons sued the City, alleging six separate causes of action. These claims included breach of contract, violation of civil rights, promissory estoppel and inverse condemnation. Five claims, all but the inverse condemnation count, were dismissed by the court prior to trial.

The promissory estoppel claim, a central issue in the dispute pertaining to an alleged promise by a former mayor, upon which the plaintiffs were seeking millions of dollars in damages, was dismissed outright by Judge Binkley in October 2019.

Binkley granted the City’s motion for summary judgement, agreeing with the City on its arguments that there was no written contract or enforceable promise to build an alley; that the City Council never approved anything other than the purchase of the property and the installation of utilities; and if then-Mayor Johnny Piper had made a verbal promise, it could not be enforced beyond his term of office; and that even if there were a promise made solely by a mayor, it is not binding on the City Council since all such actions must be approved by the City Council as a body as required by the City Charter; that the 2002 City Council could not bind future administrations to a prior mayoral promise; and that the Robinson’s claim was barred by the statute of limitations. 

And the battle continues: The Robinsons and Franklin Street Corporation have filed a motion for new trial on the inverse condemnation claim, and they have filed an appeal in the Tennessee Court of Appeals in which they argue their five other claims should not have been dismissed prior to trial. In addition, Franklin Street Corporation has recently filed yet another lawsuit in federal court alleging the same claims as in the state court action.  The City has already filed a motion to dismiss that lawsuit.

Facebook Twitter Email

Other News in All News

Keep Numbers Down

City relaxes mask requirement

Posted on: October 19, 2021
GFOA Certificate 2021

City earns 3 top financial recognitions

Posted on: October 18, 2021
City of Clarksville Auction Flyer

City to hold on-site public auction

Posted on: October 14, 2021
Clarksville Christmas Parade

2021 Christmas Parade returns December 4

Posted on: October 12, 2021
2021 Annual Report Cover Page

Mayor Presents 2021 Annual Report

Posted on: October 7, 2021

City cancels Fright on Franklin

Posted on: October 6, 2021
City of Clarksville Auction Flyer

City to Hold Public Auction

Posted on: September 29, 2021
Providence Blvd. and Peachers Mill Rd Camera

Clarksville street cameras back online

Posted on: September 23, 2021

City to seal neighborhood streets

Posted on: September 22, 2021

Employee Spotlight - William Welty

Posted on: September 20, 2021

Linda Gerron named Communications Director

Posted on: September 13, 2021

Mayor's Message: Remembering 9/11

Posted on: September 10, 2021
Powell Road Signal

Signalization to be added to Rossview Road

Posted on: September 10, 2021

Lisa Canfield named City Clerk

Posted on: September 8, 2021
2021 Riverfest Logo-01

City cancels Riverfest

Posted on: September 8, 2021

CTS route information now on Google

Posted on: September 7, 2021
District 3 Precinctt

CPD moves into new District 3 Precinct

Posted on: August 17, 2021
MPO logo

Local MPO to meet Aug. 19

Posted on: August 9, 2021
Sylvia Skinner

City Clerk Sylvia Skinner to retire

Posted on: August 9, 2021
Back to School Safety

Get ready for back-to-school traffic

Posted on: August 3, 2021
Cover Page

Transportation 2020+ moving forward

Posted on: July 22, 2021
scales of justice

City court to adopt new orders

Posted on: June 2, 2021
Billy Lee

Billy Lee named City Fleet Manager

Posted on: May 17, 2021

City to return to in-person meetings

Posted on: April 27, 2021
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

City to reopen driver services window

Posted on: March 26, 2021
Customer Social Media Posts (CTS)_LinkedIn 792x528 (App)

CTS to unveil technology upgrade

Posted on: March 18, 2021
Mask order lifted

County Mayor to lift mask order

Posted on: March 16, 2021
Clarksville Fire Rescue on scene

Franklin Street closed overnight

Posted on: March 3, 2021
Cpt. Chandler 3

More vaccination sites now available

Posted on: March 2, 2021
James Halford

Faces of Black History: James Halford

Posted on: February 27, 2021
Mask Graphic 2.27

County mask order extended to March 27

Posted on: February 26, 2021
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

County, City offices to reopen Monday

Posted on: February 21, 2021
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

City Revenue Office open Saturday

Posted on: February 19, 2021
scales of justice

City Court to resume in-person on March 16

Posted on: February 18, 2021
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

Mayors ask citizens to avoid driving

Posted on: February 14, 2021
Jimmy Terry Jr

Clarksville Faces of Black History 2

Posted on: February 12, 2021
Cover Page

Mayor to present transportation strategy

Posted on: February 9, 2021
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

Many City facilities to reopen Monday

Posted on: February 5, 2021
Wanda Smith

Clarksville Faces of Black History

Posted on: February 5, 2021

Mayor offers his case for The Roxy

Posted on: February 2, 2021
Wear a Maskv9

County mask order extended to Feb. 27

Posted on: January 27, 2021

City leaders remember Bill Forrester

Posted on: January 20, 2021

Charles W. Smith takes oath of office

Posted on: January 4, 2021
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

City offices to close New Year’s Day

Posted on: December 31, 2020

Hilborn promoted to City Project Manager

Posted on: December 29, 2020
Wear a Maskv8

County mask order extended to Jan. 29

Posted on: December 28, 2020
2020 Annual Report Cover

Mayor presents Clarksville Annual Report

Posted on: December 22, 2020

Mayors urge businesses to stress masking

Posted on: December 16, 2020
Wear a Mask v7

County mask order extended to Dec. 29

Posted on: December 9, 2020
scales of justice

City prevails in Greenway lawsuit

Posted on: December 9, 2020
iPhone - Menu

City releases new mobile app for website

Posted on: December 8, 2020
Parks Poster on Bus

CTS honoring Rosa Parks this week

Posted on: December 1, 2020
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

City offices to close for Thanksgiving

Posted on: November 24, 2020
Wear a Maskv6

County Mayor extends mask order

Posted on: November 18, 2020
City of Clarksville blue full (3)

City tax payments are due by Feb. 28

Posted on: November 13, 2020
CFR Garage

CFR breaks ground on maintenance garage

Posted on: November 12, 2020
Veterans Day 2020

CTS buses to roll on Veterans Day

Posted on: November 9, 2020
Wear a Maskv5

UPDATED: County Mayor extends mask order

Posted on: October 27, 2020

Spooky Special ready to roll again

Posted on: October 26, 2020